Ancient Tool Accuracy Science Fair Projects

Methods/Materials

To simulate the original tools a gnomon, an astrolabe, and a Ptolemy#s box were built with PVC pipe, a plum bob and wood. The three tools were tested at local noon three to four times each in two different places, Woodside California and Belize.

Results

After testing three times in Belize and four times in Woodside it was clear that the gnomon and Ptolemy's box were the most accurate tools. In Belize the gnomon's percent error was .42 degrees, Ptolemy's box's percent error was .36 degrees, and the astrolabe's percent error was .34 degrees. In Belize the gnomon's deviation was .02 degrees,Ptolemy's box's deviation was .06 degrees, and the astrolabe's deviation was 1.30 degrees.In Woodside the gnomon's percent error was .28 degrees, Ptolemy's box's percent error was .28 degrees, and the astrolabe's percent error was 1.28 degrees. In Woodside the gnomon's deviation was .22 degrees,Ptolemy's box's deviation was .19 degrees, and the astrolabe's deviation was .47 degrees.

Conclusions/Discussion

The fundamental hypothesis, that the gnomon and the astrolabe would be the most accurate was unsupported by the results. Ptolemy#s box and the Gnomon were the most accurate. This was because they were the least dependent on human intervention. The astrolabe was the least accurate and the most dependent on the skill of the tester.

There are a few faults in this project such as that light bends once it enters the hemisphere and the equations used don't take into consideration the observer is not actually in the center of the earth. The bending of light may explain why in Woodside the Results were below the actual latitude and in Belize the Results were above the actual latitude. 3rd party contributor